"just finished eating this afternoon at the restaurant and enjoyed the magaritta pizza and the honey mustard chicken wings. The service was excellent and the prices for the beer and wine were very reasonable. I will return to eat there again in the near future."
jay friedman   from   bozrah

"I like the Plum Tomato because it taste really good. I also like how in the colchester plum tomato it's a little old fasion with all the pepsi containers. It was also where i had one of my Christmas. I also like the names of the pizzas like the Godfather wich has to be my favorite. I also like how its close to where i live and the sauce tastes really good."
Noah Perkins   from   Colchester, CT

"I would have to say that I like everything about Plum Tomato. The food is always excellent as is the service. I would also have to say that the thing that has always impressed me the most is the dedication to pleasing your guests. If, on that rare occassion something doesn't come out right,there is never any hassle about doing it over. Every effort is made to satisfy the customer."
Russ Goodspeed   from   East Haddam

"The Plum Tomato in Colchester is our FAVORITE place to eat because the atmosphere is so happy, the food is scrumptious, and our KIDS love the kids menu, all at a price that the average family of four can afford. We went there last night 1/31/11 had a full meal for four and had enough money left over to go to the movies in town....that's a "Real Deal" ...that is where we saw the $5 bucks for five minutes promotion... its so convenient, a great place to eat & unwind !!...keep up the good work...."
susan santillo   from   hebron, ct

"Our favorite menu item is by far "The Kiss of Death" pizza! My husband makes all out-of-town visitors try it every time they come! We are addicted to it! We love the Plum Tomato!"
Colleen   from   Colchester

"You simply have the best pizza in town!"
Kim   from   salem

"My husband and I LOVE going to Plum Tomato and getting your famous Sammy the Bull. We always get a half so we can take the other quarter home, it is even better the next day. We are never disappointed it always tastes amazing. Thank you for being our favorite restaraunt in Colchester!!!"
Melissa Couch   from   Colchester

"My wife and I just recently moved to Colchester and were told by friends to try the Plum Tomato. We have now been here for 1 week and have eaten here 4 times! Great pizza and a really nice atmosphere. We are still learning Colchester, but at least we know where to go for pizza!"
Adam and Christina   from   Colchester

"I am addicted to SAMMY the BULL sandwich. I get one at least once a week sometimes twice a week. My friend courtney and I get one everyother friday when we get together The chicken is the best do not change a thing."
Kimberly Perkowski   from   Colchester

"Good service and good pizza for when you are in the area. A little long on the wait though."
Alison   from   Colchester

"Place is our main spot"
Vito Fornarelli   from   Colchester

"Well my husband and I are huge fans of the colchester restaurant. We absolutely love the pizza (I like the white seafood ones and my husband loves the gotti) and sandwiches (our favorites are the chicken salad and sausage), but our favorite food is your homemade garlic dressing!!! We visit you on a regular basis including both take out and sit down. Lastly, the staff is wonderful. Thanks again for your wonderful food and please keep up the good work!"
Tricia Edgar   from   Colchester

"we love plum, its the best restaurant inc town!! people are really nice there too"
amber   from   colchester ct

"One of our favorite friday night spots for dinner. The best pizza by far in CT"
Tim Sweeney   from   East Haddam CT

"Fantastic weekly cravings, can never go wrong!"
Bonnie   from   Colchester

"My husband and I bring all of our friends and family to PT when they come to visit and there is always rave reviews.. The sweet potato fries are our "go to" appetizer! My husband always says that you guys should bottle and sell your Creamy Garlic Dressing...it is awesome! It's a friendly, easy going, and comfortable place to go. I'm sure you'll eventually know my husband and I on a first name basis:)"
Sarah Beth Stonoha   from   Lebanon

"We always love going to the Plum Tomato everything tastes great. We have also hosted many soccer year end parties as well as birthday parties. The kids really enjoy making their own pizzas. we go to the Plum Tomato at least once a month."
Theresa Kennedy   from   Colchester

"My favorite menu item is the cheesy garlic bread because it is soooooo delicious and the large is the size of a pizza. yum"
Luc   from   Amston

"My favorite menu item has to be the plain cheese pizza. The sauce is the best part!"
Katie Clark   from   Norwich

"as a vegetarian - i found it hard to find food that I enjoyed, had great flavor and was filling.. the magic garden is absolutely my favorite item ... however, i am now very eager to enjoy the Anthony! Thank you for your great food for my whole family- my hubby can enjoy Mad Cow , da bomb..sammy.. and more- (he cant pick one!)"
Erin Spitale   from   baltic

"Before I started working in Colchester, I had no idea that the Plum Tomato even existed. Now, it is the ONLY place I call for pizza and also the best wings in the area."
Joe Lionetti   from   colchester

"This is one of my favorite restautants, the sandwiches are amazing and they all have corky names for them. You have to try the sammy the bull my favorite!"
Barbara   from   East Haddam

"My favorite sandwich of all time is from Plum Tomato and it is called "Sammy the Bull". The ingredients are always fresh and consistent. I also love it comes in 3 sizes, so convenient. Whenever we have an office function, I always persuade everyone that Plum Tomato is the way to go. Thank you for the wonderfully addicting food!"
Nicolette Auck   from   Norwich

"My company orders from your restaurant twice a week and the food is always outstanding! We generally get pizzas but sometimes get the sandwiches and/or wings and everything is always made properly and ready on time! Thanks for the great work!"
Manhua   from   Colchester

"Eat at least 2 times per week in your restaurant. Your sandwiches are enough for 2 people or 2 lunches. Love Sammy the Bull the Best. Don't change anything."
Dottie   from   colchester

"Being from Windsor, it was always extremely difficult to find pizza that is out-of-this-world good. Then, due to the fact that my best friends are from Colchester, I discovered The Plum Tomato, and that all changed. When I first visited The Plum Tomato with my friends, I took in the warming and welcoming vibe that the friendly wait staff and cozy decor gave off. It was then, before even tasting any food, that I realized this restaurant was a winner. We ordered fried mozzarella and a large mozzarella cheese pizza. Both dishes were amazing. The fried mozzarella was unlike any I've had before, in the sense that it was homemade, fresh, natural, and delicious, and the pizza was no different. Now, for me, nothing tops a good/great thin crust pizza, and this pizza not only exceeded my expectations, but was better than most thin crust pizzas I've had in New York City. After this first visit to The Plum Tomato, I have returned on many occasions, usually when I'm in Colchester visiting my friends, and I have yet to try something on their menu that I dislike. My friends and I do tend to order the same thing each time we visit, however, since cheese pizza and fried mozzarella is something that both the vegetarians and meat eaters can appreciate, but Plum Tomato's menu in general is full of variety for both meat eaters and vegetarians. My favorite dishes, aside from the previously-mentioned mozzarella pizza and fried mozzarella, include the El Taco pizza, the scrumptious fried dough, and the mouth-watering homemade soups, as well as some of the past Weekly Cravings specials, such as the fabulous homemade apple crisp. What we have in The Plum Tomato is a rare gem of a restaurant, and this is coming from someone with fine-dining experience. Great prices, incredible food, friendly staff, and a homey atmosphere. I really don't see how one could ask for more."
Morgan   from   Windsor, CT

"I Have always had a good experience at Plum Tomato with the service and the quality of the food. If i could suggest one change to be made i would like to see wings available in the Salem location."
Matt Fortier   from   Moodus

"I love the brickini sandwiches, I've tried at least half of the and never have been disappointed and always have a good experience with the service and quality of Plum Tomato, The only thing i would like to see changed in selling chicken wings out of the Salem location as thats where i go more often and the wings are great too."
Nicole Schiavone   from   East Haddam, ct

"Several friends and I celebrated my birthday at the Plum Tomato. Every single one of my firends are Italians, who have all worked in and owned Italian restaurants, so they are a picky crowd! Every food item ordered, from the Spinach Salad to the God father pizza, was critqued, discussed and enjoyed. The final analysis? Plum Tomato has the freshest/best-tasting food, an extensive/comical menu and helpfl/friendly staff. We all agreed it was one of the best Italian restaurants around (and the most cost effective)!"
Karen Lee Muir   from   Colchester

"Wow! The smell when you open the door-heaven! Whoever picks up the order races home or can't wait and tears into it before they get home! The shhepish look on their faces always gives them away and we know they have already started dinner. If there is fresh bread when we get there, then that is what gets eaten on the way home. When the girls have been away at college and I mention Plum Tomato, their faces light up! Keep us drooling for many years to come!"
Louise Plack   from   Oakdale

"My favorite menu item is the sweet potatoe fris because they offer all the greatness of sweet potatoes and that yummy whit sour cream garlic stuff that comes with it tastes good. I could eat it daily!"
Kelly   from   Colchester

"My husband and I were at the Plum Tomato in Colchester to celebrate my birthday. We were excited to use the birthday coupon I received online. I decided to try a different pizza from the one I usually have and ordered a pizza with sausage on it. The pizza was good but the sausage was unusually hot (spicy). Our server was so helpful! He offered us some options and ultimately deducted the price of the sausage. We love the pizza at Plum Tomato and the wait-staff is always friendly and helpful."
Ellen Downie   from   Oakdale

"We ordered the Michael Angelo and it was so incredible, the flavors meld together perfectly!! We love the place because of the atmosphere with the chairs and tables being so different, I loved that. I had my son's birthday party there too and he just loved making his own pizza...what a great concept! It's right in town and the prices are very reasonable. The staff is very pleasant so I can't say that I will choose one over the others. I don't think there is anything I would change about this place! I love going there, it's been a treat everytime! Thank you."
Lucy Nadeau   from   Colchester

"What is your favorite menu item and why? Love the pope! It is so delicious and fresh, not greasy, and the ingredients are never bad."
Luc Richard   from   Amston, CT

"Plum tomato has the best pizza near us and our toddler loves going there."
Alejandro   from   Andover, CT

"My favorite thing at Plum Tomato is creamy garlic dressing! I put it on my salad and I dip my pizza crust in it. One of the best dressings I've ever had, It's delicious. One thing to imrpove on is the tables. Sometimes it is tough for us tall people to find a table where we dont hit our legs on the awkward table legs, since none of the tables match, I have narrowed it down to a few that I look for when I dine in, but getting table booths might be something to consider."
Kim   from   Colchester

"In response to: If you could suggest a new menu item, what would it be and why? I always enjoy a meal at Plum. However, there is one item I feel should be added to the every day menu. The buffalo chicken wrap! It's the best wrap in town; when it's available... It should also come with french fries. Other venues have a wrap with fries and it's also cheaper. However, I'd pay the extra couple dollars for your buffalo chicken wrap. Other than that everything seems great whenever we dine there. Sometimes it takes a while to get the food, but worth the wait."
Josh Slack   from   East Hampton

"My first visit to the Plum Tomato was 2 weeks ago, and I have been craving it ever since! I only had time to order off of the take-out menu but the service was extremely fast and the staff had some helpful suggestions. The pizza and sandwiches were cooked to perfection and the combination on the sandwich was delicious. It makes me want to come back and try everything on the menu. I hope to have time to have a sit down meal next time to fully enjoy the cozy atmosphere. Can't wait to go back!"
Jackie   from   Portland, CT

"I absolutely LOVE plum tomato! My favorite pizza is their blazzin' saddles but I have to say that everything I have ever ordered there was AWESOME!!!! Plus the staff is always happy and friendly! It is just simply a GREAT place to go :)"
Mary   from   Colchester

"The Godfather is the king of all pizzas! It's simply delicious, delectable da godfather!!"
pablo   from   colchester

"I am a big fan of your salads. Your Bleu Cheese dressing might be the best Ive had. ! If I had to make a suggestion it would be to add your Bacon Mac and Cheese to your everyday menu! That tasted great, and I would definitly love to get some more!"
Scott Harrington   from   Colchester

"This is my favorite place for a GOOD vegetarian variety. I LOVE the veggie Italian sausage patties and the fact that PT will customize any order. Keep up the great work, guys (and girls)"
Brenda   from   Colchester

"I've been going to plum tomato for years. The pizza is always hot and fresh, and really is the best pizza around. I've tried other nearby pizza shops, and none of them compare. great work!"
Ben Kopchick   from   Hebron (Colchester Location)

"I have always enjoyed the atmosphere of the Colchester resturant. The pizza is amazing, a great thin crust. I love the sandwiches!! Sammy the Bull is the greastest!! Thank you also for how wonderful you all have been when I have taken my girl scouts in the past. Always a favorite when our daughters where young!"
Kelly Hahn   from   Colchester

"Best pizza is a toss up between the Michaleangelo and the Kiss of Death. However, KOD is sometimes not the same and onions are not caramelized only white. Only real complain (at Salem location). Potato on pizza is great, if I could combined the two.....LOOK OUT. Thanks for great pizza."
Chad Brown   from   Waterford

"Love your sandwiches. Always enough to feed both myself and my husband. Get the sandwich at least once a week. Sammy the Bull is my favorite. Thank you for always being friendly."
Dottie   from   colchester

"I love the fact that you will make any sandwich a salad, Sammy the Bull is the best! We always use you for our company catering needs and its always a big hit!"
Cheryl   from   Colchester

"My husband and I eat at PT at least once a week; we LOVE the wings and the pizza. And of course, the staff (especially those working on Sunday nights) are the best! We enjoyed when you had beer specials advertised on the blackboard .... a lower price might encourage me to try a new beer! I would love to see a frequent visitor card or special. For example, buy 5 pizzas, get the next one free. Keep up the great work!"
Sherrill Woessner   from   Colchester

"We are regulars at Plum Tomato, feels almost like our home away from home because of the warm and friendly atmosphere. We enjoy all of the people who work at PT, always friendly, service is always great! I'm a vegetarian so it's great to go to a restaurant that has several very tasty vegetarian options, my favorite as probably all of the staff at PT knows is the vegetarian chili! Jack loves the Gelato, and while I'm enjoying my glass of wine I grab a few bites of it from him. So, to sum up how we feel about PT, great food, fun atmosphere, great staff, great service, great prices! See you soon. Carol & Jack"
Carol Palen   from   Marlborough

"I just love coming in to your Colchester restaurant. The comfortable and casual atmosphere is appreciated. I come in for your pizza and almost always order the same one- the white pizza with spinich and mushrooms and triple fresh garlic. My favorite server is Zac, who always has a smile and is very friendly. I would love to see a whole wheat crust created for a more healthy option. Also, please continue with the wonderful greens you use for your salads. It is refreshing to not get iceburg lettuce as so many other pizza places do."
Christine Holland   from   Lebanon CT

"The Plum Tomato is one of my favorite places to eat for a truly fun experience with friends and food. My favorite item on the menu is The Sinatra. My mother's maiden name is Sinatra, so when I first came to The Plum Tomato I knew that I had to try out the pizza named after the Commander in Chief. It turns out that the pizza is delicious! Every time I stop by for a pizza, this is the one that I order, and my friends agree that its delicious combination of toppings is heavenly. I often crave The Sinatra. It is calling for me... come back!"
Krista Annecharico   from   East Hampton

"What is your favorite menu item and why? The "Ali" because the sausage is more ground up which gives it the great taste without the overall clumsiness of a traditional sausage sandwich...very yummy! I love how well thought every sandwich is. There is definitely a lot of love and creativity put into each sandwich...keep it up!"
Alan   from   Colchester

"The Plum Tomato is a true gem is all aspects. Whether I pop in for a slice in Salem (last visit 11/29) or dine with friends in Colchester (last visit 11/11), the experience is excellent. The staff is always polite and helpful with recommendations, although my favorite is the Umberto and Da Vinci pizzas. I highly recommend their catering services too - on time delivery, huge portions, and great suggestions when selecting from the menu (party was 2/20)! Keep up the good work."
Tina McCurdy   from   East Haddam

"I find their food consistant, priced well and service is always good. I love doing take out."
Jane Erway   from   Lebanon

"What is your favorite menu item and why? my favorite item is the godfather pizza. there are so many different flavors conflicting with each other but at the same time combining together to make an awesome ending taste. i always treat other people to it when i buy pizzaa because its so delicious."
margarita robida   from   colchester

"LOVE your food. my favorite is the TPT pizza it has the best of everything but sometimes being creative with all your great toppings is great. Last time tried your fatti and brickini for the first time...love the fatti bread..so fresh! Also the best wings...love the hawaiian sauce. Your decor is so relaces which is why we like it, eclectic and mismatched very comfortable,the camp plates are a small nice touch also...not the usual a great twist ...the only thing that would make it the PT better is an outdoor patio in the summer! BTW your help is always so friendly always happy and smiling and in a good mood. We rave about your food to everyone!"
Jason Griffing   from   East Haddam

"I love the great variety on the menu. I especially love the unique pizzas. I enjoy a good vegetarian pizza and the Plum Tomato gives me many choices. My favorite is the Matino. Most veggie pizzas only have one or two items but this pizza has artichokes and fire roasted peppers in addition to broccoli, mushrooms and onions. The crust is chewy and reminds me of my Mom's homemade pizzas. Keep up the good work. Celeste Lagonick"
Celeste Lagonick   from   Marlborough

"The last time that I ate at Plum Tomato was every bit as good as the first time. I ordered my favorite sandwich, Sammy the Bull (try it now, thank me later,) on Fatti bread (baked to perfection in the brick oven of course.) Sarah waited on us and as usual she was polite, attentive, and super helpful. As if the food weren't enough to keep us coming back the smiling and energetic staff always make Plum Tomato worth the trip. The playful atmosphere, great food, and fun staff make Plum Tomato my favorite casual restaurant. In a town with no shortage of pizza places, Plum Tomato’s unique offerings and weekly specials will keep you coming back again and again. Now I've made myself hungry... I know where I'm going for dinner!"
Edward A Horn   from   Colchester

"just love the warm brickini sandwiches. so many to choose from. never get bored!"
tonya harris   from   salem

"My favorite menu item is Sammy the bull without Bacon and gorganzola. I like this sandwich the best, because I like the way the bread is toasted and the way the chicken is sliced. The roasted peppers give it just the right taste, and the dressing gives it an extra great taste."
Danielle   from   Salem

"bY FAR, THE BEST PIZZA THAR i HAVE EVER HAD. tHE STAFF IS ALWAYS FRIENDLY AND COURTEOUS."
LOUISE vICHAS   from   bOZRAH

"Although there are alot of pizza places around, we try to make the trip to Plum Tomato in Colchester at least once a week (my husband gets a craving!!); we love their brick oven pizza,their wings and the garlic dressing. Their prices are reasonable, the service is good and the servers are friendly. They could use a bigger space as sometimes the wait can be abit long and I love the brick oven for the pizza, just wish they had a way to crisp the wings up a little more for my taste. Overall, great food at a great value...very casual."
Karen Wilson   from   Uncasville, CT

"My last visit at The Plum Tomato was awesome! Everyone there is super nice, and everyone works effeciently to serve the customers. I got my food fast and it was delecious. I love your wings and pizza; and i plan on eating there again and again!"
Jessica M   from   Amston

"The atmosphere is awesome, everyone is always smiling and inviting not to mention the pizza is awesome! My favorite menu item is the pizza with bacon and tomato. Love the crust! also, great wings, always love to try new flavors."
Erica Woodward   from   Andover

"The TPT is our favorite pizza; the thin crust and all the goodies on top and when we come to pick it up, the young person waiting on us is proud to show it to us; its as if she or he made it themselves just for us; bottom line is we can't wait to get home to eat it!"
Fred Dole   from   Colchester

"The PT is the BEST pizza place in town! For lunch, dinner or take out our family knows we will always get fresh high quality food at a great price! and the cheesy garlic bread is bar far the BEST!! no matter what we order- its always in the mix! It's so good- i know we are addicted!!"
Maureen Gay   from   Colchester

"I think PT has some of the best pizza and wings in this part of the state especially the Teryaki wings and also love trying out the weekly cravings specials. A personal favorite was the pierogi special."
Jesse   from   Colchester

"I have two favorites at the Plum Tomato. The Momma Rosa pizza is awesome. Being a vegetarian it's nice to have something a little more unusual. Love the gorgonzola! The best Four Bean Salad in the world is also found here. I've tried to recreate it myself but it's never as good. These are my favorites for now but I haven't tried the blondie lasagne yet so I might have a new one in the near future!"
Kellee Ratzer   from   Colchester

"I LOE EGGPLANT! EVERY SO OFTEN YOU OFFER A DISH CALLED STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN. HERE IS MY DESCRIPTION OF THE IDEAL DREAM DISH: LAYERS OF EGGPLANT WITH TOMATO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA, AND MUSHROOM SLICES BETWEEN LAYERS AND A LARGE MUSHROOM CAP ON TOP WITH PARMESANCHEESE OVER IT."
PAULA WEBER   from   MARLBOROUGH

"Always fantastic food and the staff are happy and polite. The choices on the menu make my decision difficult, but I haven't had one bad thing on the menu! Keep up the good work making fantastic food and a great dining atmosphere!"
Matthew Flegert   from   Lebanon CT

"Love your sandwiches. Sammy the Bull is the best. Use your restaurant for catering (pizza) and everyone loves it. The only thing that we always have to do when ordering is to ask for the pizza to be lightly cooked. Alot of people do not like the burnt crust. Keep up the good work as everyone is super friendly when I come in to the restaurant."
carole   from   colchester

"You have build your own pizza options on the menu which is great. I would suggest a build your own option for the sandwiches. Provide a list of meats, cheeses, dressing and veggies. People are always wanting to change or sub an item so why not let them build it from scratch. You could also have forms for them to check off the items they want to keep it easy on the waitr staff and cooks."
John Murray   from   East Lyme

"I absolutely love the brickini sandwiches. I am a vegetarian and I love that I can get a delicious sandwich made that is pilled with fresh veggies."
Kelli Boiselle   from   East Lyme

"Everything was great the last time I ate at Plum. My favorite meal is the blazin' saddles pizza. The only suggestion that I have is to carry more selection for the hosmer mountain soda....preferably cherry cola and black cherry. Will be back in very soon! :)"
Jennifer Moroch   from   Colchester

"Love the food and atmosphere at Plum Tomato. The Sammy the Bull sandwich and God Father pizza both rock! Food criticism: The sandwiches used to be more full. Atmosphere criticism: It's hard to make a connection between the name (Plum Tomato) and the decor (old movie posters and signs). It's cool but maybe doesn't fit with the name IMO."
Rob   from   Colchester

"I'm a big fan of the Tater Tail.. it is flavorful and moist but is not runny and doesn't fall apart!"
Jen   from   Colchester

"The Plum Tomato has the best pizza ever. I love it there."
Cathy   from   Colchester

"If you think The Plum Tomato is just pizza, you should stop in and see why it's more! We often order more than we can eat just so we can have some the next day. There are many tasty flavors of the wings we dig into. I have had awesome pasta dishes, my favorite being a special of vegetable ravioli in a creamy cheese sauce-yum. The staff is energetic, polite, and friendly. We have even had some catering done. Erin was very helpful in creating something to meet our dining needs. Stop in and eat or pick up some good food and support a local business, you won't be disappointed."
Nicole Beaulieu   from   Colchester

"We moved to East Haddam 3 years ago. We enjoy pizza and Plum tomato has some of the best pizza in the area. The roasted garlic on the pizza is delicous and a wonderful topping. The staff if friendly and helpful. WE recommend the Plum Tomato to our firnds and neighbors and plan to continue coming to both locations in Salem and Colchester. out only suggestion is to open one in East Haddam to make it even more convenient to order weekly."
Lisa Brandes   from   East Haddam

"The Plum Tomato is my family's favorite restaurant! We like to alternate between the bacon & plum tomato pizza and the brickini sandwiches. The food is always fantastic and the prices very reasonable! Keep it up!"
Jesse   from   Moodus

"We have loved Plum Tomato since the first time we came! We love their pizza, wings, and like trying different weekly cravings! Our kids love the grilled cheese pizza. Our favorite has to be The Godfather."
Virginia Paquette   from   Lebanon

"Your staff rocks!! your take-out Pizza's are always perfect, hot and delicious... You have a customer forever!!!! Thanks Gail"
gail miers   from   colchester

"The ingredients in your pizza taste very fresh. Also, your well balanced combination of sauce and cheese on a great thin crust, are a real hit with us."
james tomasek   from   ellington, ct

"Plum Tomato has a great feature, they advertise right to you every week for their weekend specials! We love to order on Friday nights from you guys, and this makes life very simple. You should always include the gorgonzola pesto garlic bread, we anxiously await that every time!"
jeffrey blumberger   from   Colchester, Ct

"My favorite menu item? Can't choose just one! For appetizers, definitely the HOT wings - just enough heat & good flavor (some places just go for heat). My husband & I keep trying different varities of the pizza, but always return to the DOA! All of the Brickinis we've had have been excellent, but I'm partial to the Caesar Salami."
Jennifer   from   Colchester

"Everytime our family comes to visit they want to order your pizza...yes, because it is addictive!! Speaking of addictive, my husband and his friends LOVE your wings and order them all the time!!!"
Dina Graham   from   Colchester

"What is your favorite menu item and why? I love the Frederico pizza with creamy garlic sauce! It's an awesome blend of ingredients and the garlic sauce is unique to your restaurant! We like other pizza places in town, but I find myself continually ordering from you because I like the creamy garlic sauce so much! I REALLY missed the Frederico during my recent pregnancy b/c I couldn't eat gorgonzola cheese. I've been making up for it ever since! What do you like about the atmosphere at the Plum Tomato? I like the atmosphere at The Plum Tomato because it's low key. The eclectic mix of tables/chairs, cool memorabilia, and relaxed mood make it a relaxing meal instead of a meal where I feel like I need to be on my best behavior. We almost always choose to bring family/friends there when they're visiting because it's so relaxed. What is the one thing that you return to the Plum Tomato for? Creamy garlic sauce! I also love that you guys carry Hosmer sodas! What could we do to make you come in more often? If there were more coupons/promotions, we would probably eat there or order out more often. I'm staying home with a baby right now and money is going to be tight for awhile on one income, but coupons seem to entice us to eat pizza. It seems that Papa Z's and Cafe Mangia are the only ones in town that offer regular promotions. We love Cafe Mangia, as well, but don't eat there as regularly due to the budget factor."
Katherine Loiselle   from   Colchester, CT

"With all the other local Pizza options Plum Tomato's Pizzas becomes the default location for my family. The white pizza selection is great, The Vinny seems to be our favorite. Wings are pretty good too."
mitch   from   Colchester

"My favorite thing about the Plum Tomato is the Weekly Cravings. I really enjoy seeing the post on facebook every Thursday for the following week's. Your ideas are really unique and delicious. I especially love how you cater to the vegetarian community. Not only are many of your Cravings vegetarian friendly, but so is a lot of your regular menu! My family loves the food at the Plum Tomato... we have our regular menu items (cheesie bread, the Pope), but I really enjoy changing it up once in a while when I see your Cravings! Thanks!"
Erin   from   Colchester

"Our favorite TWO items are the Michelangelo and Godfather pizzas. One of us is a vegetarian and the other is not so these two suit us just fine in a single pizza or two separate ones when we have friends in. We are so fortunate to have one excellent pizza house in town that is waist, head, and shoulders above all the others. We don't know what we would do for pizza if Plum Tomato were not in town. Probably skip pizza altogether."
Tricia & Cal   from   Colchester

"We love the Plum Tomato... getting their pizza takeout has become a favorite weekend routine for when we're too tired to cook. If you are going to order a Brickini, its necessary to eat them there right when they come out of the oven for best taste (THE BEST!!). The sweet potato fries are pretty awesome if you eat them in-house as well. The staff varies - we've had experiences with super-fast, professional service, but also others who ran a little slow and seemed new. Still love this place regardless."
Nicole Brookshier   from   Colchester

"I love the Plum Tomato's plain cheese pizza because the crust has just the right crunchiness without being hard. The cheese gets golden brown, not only mozzarella white. I believe they put a little cheddar to make it brown which a lot of pizza places are too cheap to do. A plain cheese pizza is the way to tell if a pizza is great or not and their's is!"
Kathy Snyder   from   Colchester

"excellent pizza, my sisters and i had the florentine. it was ready upon my arrival, this was my first visit to a plum tomato restaurant, i like the fact you have a separate entrance as takeout---very convenient. thanks"
mary beth running   from   norwich

"Although there are several pizza places in our area, we would rather drive the half hour to Plum Tomato in Colchester. They have the best pizza and wings and at a reasonable price. The staff is friendly and attentive no matter how busy. We leave there full and with leftovers! If you haven't been, you're really missing a treat!"
Karen Wilson   from   Uncasville

"The best pizza in the area.Crust was just right and toppings did not overwhelm the sauces. Will return to try the panninis."
Donna   from   Jewett City

"The food is great and the prices can't be beat."
Jamison   from   Hanover

"The service at The Plum Tomato was great, I look forward to going next week."
Jill   from   Colchester

"I'm a big fan of The Bishop, it always hits the spot!"
Noel   from   Colchester